Mike The Fanboy’s List of the Top Ten Best and Worst Autograph Signers For 2011!
Every year there are the best and worst lists, well this is no different. You know I think that this list is at least somewhat important. I think the average moviegoing consumer should know that when they lay their money down, watch a television series, download a song from I-Tunes etc… which celebrities welcome fans and are kind. They should also know which celebrities are jerks. LOL…
So, we at Mike The Fanboy have put together a list of the top ten best and worst autograph signers of 2011. Now, none of us are dealers who flip 30 photos on someone, we are all fans who do not sell. So, this literally comes directly from the fans, and the way we did this list is compiled all out best and worst experiences this year. Period. If someone was nice and signed one item, I think that’s a great signer. This was based on not only how celebrities signed autographs but also who is and who is not fan friendly.
Let’s get to it after the jump!
_________________________________________________________________________________
THE TOP 10 BEST AND MOST FAN FRIENDLY AUTOGRAPH SIGNERS OF 2011!
10. Matt Bomer – The White Collar star is one of the nicest guys you could ever possibly come across. I’ve seen him stay for hours and hours signing autographs and taking photos with fans without even flinching. One of the kindest, most fan friendly people out there!
9. Chris Hemsworth – The man known as Thor this summer was literally hounded everywhere he went. And everywhere he went… He stopped and took time for fans… After talk show tapings… At the Thor Premiere… At random events… He signed at them all. Time will tell if this continues, but for 2011, he was pretty damn awesome!
8. Harrison Ford – Mr. Indiana Jones has had an interesting history with fans. There were years when Mr. Ford was not so fan friendly, but this year… Man, he signed everywhere he went. It was crazy! Now, Harrison did not really do photos and kept his limit at one per person, but it was rare to hear him not signing when politely asked.
7. Mark Ruffalo – The second Avenger on this list, Mark Ruffalo has proven many times this year what an awesome guy he is. It doesn’t matter how many people there are, Mark Ruffalo takes time out to greet each and everyone… With a smile.
6. Mark Wahlberg – Even this year has been quieter than most for Mark Wahlberg, he still is one of the nicest celebrities out there. He always takes time out for fans, and will sign anything you put in front of him. Where many celebrities will flinch at signing their older stuff (i.e. the infamous Calvin Klein shots) Mark has no problem with it. Class act all the way.
5. Dustin Hoffman – An acting legend, Mr. Hoffman is literally so kind that he will joke around with fans while signing, take photos, and in the case of Pinky take her dog down the line signing at the Kung Foo Panda 2 premiere. That’s rare in this hobby!
4. Jon Favreau – The Cowboys and Aliens director is a fanboy at heart. As Big Mike has said, “This is one man who understands the fans.” And that he does. Even when he’s rushed he does what he can. simply put there should be more celebrities like him!
3. Lady Gaga – There is one thing about a celebrity stopping and being nice to fans, but it’s another when you meet someone who is at the top of the food chain. However, Lady Gaga always takes time out for fans, and with the kind of passionate fans she has, you just never know how they are going to react when they are in front of her. Each time Lady Gaga is patient and gives as much time as she can.
2. Angelina Jolie and Brad Pitt – Yes, they are a twosome but both are quite a pair to their fans. Angie is simply put one of the kindest people and one of the best autograph signers out there. Brad might be tougher, but he’s still really good to his fans as well.
1. Johnny Depp – Johnny is so nice to his fans, so so nice. I don’t think there has even been a premiere where he doesn’t sign or greet the fans. CB even said that they set up barricades at the Rum Diary premiere, because Johnny wanted to meet his fans. This is very rare in a day and age when a lot of celebs try to avoid their fans!
Honorable Mentions for 2011: Anton Yelchin, Rob Pattinson, Taylor Lautner, Colin Firth, Gary Oldman, Christian Bale, Cloris Leachman, Elijah Wood, Ashton Kutcher, Stephen Moyer, Anna Paquin, Alexander Skarsgard.
THE TOP TEN LEAST FAN FRIENDLY AUTOGRAPH SIGNERS OF 2011
10. Molly Ringwald – I know it’s not 1985 but so many of us here are huge fans of the 1980’s and so the classic stars of the 1980s. Molly Ringwald is very harsh to fans, and has given me the look of death so many times this year even Pinky has refused to ask her again for a photo. You would think she was the hottest thing on the planet!
9. Edie Falco – Every year comes and every year goes, and with each passing year I look forward to the annual diss from Edie Falco. I have literally been trying to get Ms. Falco for about… oh four to five years now, and each time… The annual diss, it’s almost a tradition at this point!
8. Darius Rucker – I’m not sure if one encounter earns someone being on this list, but the way it all happened, yeah… I think it does. Darius Rucker ran out after ignoring fans all day, and then told Pinky, that she needs to get a life and he has a life outside of “this.” I’m assuming “This” means music. Ah well… I never actually thought he made real “music” anyway!
7. Joseph Gordon-Levitt – Yep, the 3rd Rock from the Sun star is leaving fans in the dust. I used to be a huge fan until I saw his behavior first hand… Wow, and this year I hear it’s only getting worse. Ignoring fans, smiling in people’s faces while saying, “No! I can’t sign!”
6. John Goodman – I’ve went out for Mr. Goodman a couple times this year and both times I was completely ignored. Barely a wave, and rarely an acknowledgement. It was sad actually because Dan Connor, John Goodman is not!
5. Steve Buscemi – It’s like a Big Lebowski diss for 2011! Steve has not only dissed people on many different occasions, but he loves to do the fake phone call. I hate the fake phone call more than anything. Like suddenly you get a call and can’t hear the screaming fans? Really, that call, it’s that important? I’ve even heard him tell people when asked for a quick autograph, “Yeah right.”
4. Sam Rockwell – Man, this guy is a piece of work. There’s a reason Sam Rockwell always plays such shady characters, cause he’s so shady. When Erica was in New York, Sam had a cup of coffee in his hand and just couldn’t put it in another hand to sign her poster, even though he told her, “Wow, that’s cool.” At the Zookeeper premiere, he didn’t even look over at people.
3. Catherine O’Hara – Now, Catherine has always been a bit prickly, but this year the Best in Show star was downright nasty. At an event earlier this year, Catherine was waiting for her car for over 30 minutes, would she come over to sign just for me? Nope, it was a battle of wills, for all 30 minutes… The crowd started to turn on her, with one guy yelling, “Come on Catherine, it’s just one guy…” Then when Catherine tried to hide, he yelled, “We can still see you Catherine!” At one point the press even turned on her with one journalist saying, “I think she broke her hand.” Nasty.
2. Sarah Michelle Gellar – Wow, this one was so sad. Sarah has never been the nicest celebrity but I heard she was mellowing… I guess not. She wouldn’t even look at people, whether it was on set, at promotional events, nothing. Big Mike had a great recap of his experience going out for her earlier this year, that summ up what I feel like about Ms. Gellar as well. It’s sad, maybe she should re-watch episodes of her old series.
1. Natalie Portman – Hands down the worst least fan friendly celebrity ever! Like, shockingly bad. At the No Strings Attached premiere, she wouldn’t even look over even though we were so close w could have spit on her. Independent Spirit awards, again nadda. During a Black Swan Q and A a fan asked for a photo, Natalie ignored him, so he asked again, she turned to him and said, “If I didn’t answer you the first time what makes you think I’m going to answer you the second.” Talk about showing your true colors!
Honorable Mentions: Charlize Theron, Claire Danes, Sofia Vergara, Ed O’Neil, Ed Norton, Ben Affleck, Chris Pine, John Cho
Share on Facebook
That sucks about JGL not signing at all. I’m surprised to see Chris Pine on the list of non signers. I got him TTM via Unstoppable so I’m all good, but yeah surprising.
Totally happy to see Harrison Ford and Chris Hemsworth on the good signers list. I have a full sized Temple poster I’d love to get signed, and my Thor poster signed by Stan that is just begging for a Hemsworth on it too. You make me wish I lived in LA some days. Cool to see Rob Pattinson on the honorable mention list. I have a few full sized posters I’d love him on, none of which are Twilight Ironically. 🙂
Great job Mike! As I scrolled through this slowly because I wanted to savor every moment of the worst signer list, I have to tell you, when I got to SMG being at #2 I thought “What the hell? Who could POSSIBLY be worse to her fans than SMG?!?!?!” Then I read what happened with Portman. Wow. I’ve never tried for her because I’ve heard that she treats her fans worse than the gum on the bottom of her shoe, but wow. I hope she realizes that she did in fact answer him the second time, so maybe that’s a win for him? Also, at least for me Edward Norton needs to be tied up there with Ms. Portman. I don’t think I can even talk about my experience with him anymore without breaking into hives and a 2 hour phone call to my therapist. As for JGL, being one of 5 fans one night waiting for him to sign and him insisting for about 5 minutes that he couldn’t sign (he could have knocked out all our autos in 1 minute), the night before his movie 50/50 opened I experienced first hand how little he cares about his fans.
Johnny Depp is by far the most gracious of stars to his fans :). Maybe I’ll see you again out there on the sidelines…but I feel about SMG the way Pinky feels about Ringwald. Now when the hell is Ringer getting cancelled!?
I have to give honorable mention to Jim Sturgess. He will sign and sign…and write complete quotes for you. Totally cool to his fans. : )
All the Whedonverse talent is wonderful to their fans.
I’m happy to see Rob Pattinson got an honorable mention! 🙂
I also met Mark Ruffalo and Mark Wahlberg earlier this year as well and agree with everything you said. Both are two of the coolest and nicest celebs I have ever met. Ruffalo was signing everything put in front of him, shaking people’s hands and taking photos as well. Like you point out Mike, Wahlberg is really not ashamed to sign anything from his past and super cool about signing old stuff. They are both very down to earth and super chill.
Jospeh Gordon Levitt has gotten less fan friendly. For a special release party at Amoeba earlier this year for his side project Hit Record, he pulled out of doing an autograph signing super last minute. Even staff were shocked and his reason to them “he was too busy to sign autographs.” Even average fans were pissed off when they heard the news and tried to start a Twitter trend dissing him. Very few celebs today truly know how to appreciate their loyal fans. If BIG names like Johnny Depp, Angelina Jolie and Lady Gaga can do it (even though they are some of the biggest entertainers in the world), most celebs should be more fan friendly and take note from those A-listers.
I’m a little surprised by Charlize Theron (having met her twice), but I guess her signing habits have changed since her split with Stuart Townsend. Also why no love for George Clooney? I met him not that long ago while he was promoting The Descendants and he was seriously one of the coolest guys ever when he signed a DVD for me. Still, love the list and can’t wait to read more!
Any year where Harrison Ford makes the Best Signer list is a GREAT year! I managed to get a rare photo op with him, not once but TWICE! (at the same event, thankfully he had a few drinks in between 🙂 )
As for the Honorable Mentions for Best Signers, I’d like to mention the cast of It’s Always Sunny In Philadelphia. Danny Devito has always been great, Charlie Day has been really nice whenever I’ve seen him. I have yet to meet Glenn Howerton but I’ve heard nice things about him. But Rob McElheney & Kaitlin Olsen? They would be on my top 10 BEST list every year! Those two really go above and beyond with signing and taking photo ops with the fans. I watched them work the crowds during and after Danny Devito’s Star Ceremony, any they exceeded everyone’s expectations. Very gracious and accomodating to each and every fan.
As for Honorable Mention for Worst Signer, I’d like to mention John Lasseter. I’ve had great luck with him in the past, but this year he was just plain fan-unfriendly!! He wouldn’t even sign a Cars 2 poster for a kid at the hotel after the premiere! I don’t know what happened to him, but the first and only time I’ve gotten him (multiples!!) he was so incredibly gracious, that it was just shocking how he’s behaved this year.
I would move Alexander Skarsgard off of honorable mentions and into the top 10 best signers — the man stops for fans every time I’ve seen him. He even invited me to take a picture when I was taking pictures for others. How many other people would actually ask if you wanted something!?!!
And another reason why Johnny Depp is the best signer — he went INTO the bleachers and signed for the 200+ kids watching the arrivals at Rango. He signed autographs for over an hour (!!!!) and spent maybe 20 minutes with the press. There is a man who values his fans!
I hope some of these stars read this website and realize what idiots they look like!! spending a little while with their fans reaps big rewards!